Part of the Do'a Iftitah

"Verily my solats, my ibadah, my life and my death I surrender to Almighty Allah, Creator and Lord of all the worlds. Never will I associate anything with Him. So am I commanded and I am of those who are Muslims."

The Muslim Bloggers Alliance

The Muslim Bloggers Alliance
Bringing Muslim Bloggers Together

Friday, September 14, 2007

Malaysian Opposition - Are they able to deliver an alternative government?

We all know that the current BN government is not actually the best form of government to lead Malaysia to a better, just future for all.

A government that is made up of individual politicians whether from the current BN Coalition or the Opposition BA made up of PAS, DAP and the PKR will always be straddled with problematic ministers because it is human nature to forget one's oath of being an upright, honest to goodness public servant once power and its trappings starts to get at the elected or appointed individual.

The BN Coalition of UMNO, MCA, MIC, GERAKAN and other minor political parties have been running the government since this nation came into being.

Through the years, we have seen this country slowly but surely transform itself physically in the form of developments in infrastructure and its consequent modernization of the people's lifestyle especially those living in the cities and suburban areas.

This development will continue to take place if the nation is led by responsible persons in authority and our country has seen that take place especially during the premiership of Tun Dr.Mahathir Mohamad, the 4th Prime Minister after Tunku Abdul Rahman, Tun Abdul Razak and Tun Hussein Onn.

Mahathir's tenure as the PM lasted 22 years and he was able to initiate and bring about Malaysia to be what it is today.

Problems especially the scourge of corruption and abuses of power by elected and appointed officials are the norm in any country but it is something that can be avoided or handled effectively if the offenders are duly taken to task and punished according to the laws of the land.

The whitewashing and acquitting of corrupt ministers and officials has become a trend here in Malaysia and 4 years after the incumbent premier took over control and power from Tun Mahathir, the situation remains the same if not worse!

What I would like to know is whether the nation's Opposition consisting of the 3 political parties of PAS, DAP and PKR are able to give us a better effective alternative government to replace the current BN?

Talk is cheap. Any aspiring politician can say this or that and castigate the current ruling government but the reality is whether the Barisan Alternatif @ BA can deliver what they seem to promise?

What lineup does the BA have for us?

Have they come to an agreement or compromise between them?

Whom do they propose as their choice to be our alternative Prime Minister?

Which party is actually ready to form the next government if let's say the people of Malaysia do decide that they have had enough of the BN?

I have yet to hear of PAS and DAP be able to sit together and come to terms between them especially about the issue of PAS wanting to turn Malaysia into a truly Islamic State or nation by upholding and implementing the true Laws of Almighty Allah @ the Islamic Syaria to be the Supreme Constitution of Malaysia and the matter of the DAP wanting to turn this nation into a Malaysia for Malaysians where the current system of giving preferential treatment to the Malays as Bumiputra's will be removed and all Malaysians supposedly will be treated the same?

That's the same hype that we hear take place down south in Singapore but the reality is that the Singapore Malays have been sidelined by the PAP Government since day one when Lee Kuan Yew became the Prime Minister of that island republic.

The DAP is our version of the Singapore PAP. As we all know the DAP is made up of mostly the Chinese ethnicity.

For all the melodrama and theatrics that politicians will put up, reality will come home to roost in form of preferential treatment to cronies and nepotism which we see take place in almost every political party.

This is prevalent in the DAP but the situation is not there in PAS. The situation in PKR is that we have Anwar Ibrahim, the deposed former Deputy Prime Minister during Tun Mahathir's tenure as Premier declaring himself to be the 'de facto' leader of PKR which is being led by his wife, Wan Azizah.

Things aren't exactly hunky dory in PKR with the recent defections of several prominent leaders from the party which was set up mainly to fight for the release of Anwar from imprisonment and after his release during Abdullah Badawi's premiership after taking over from Mahathir.

So to me, I doubt whether the so called alternative coalition of the 3 Opposition parties have for us an alternative lineup of their proposed government to replace and remove the BN from power come the next General Elections?

Has PAS and DAP made peace between them yet?

From what I know, both parties have yet to come to a compromise or agreement about the subject of making Malaysia an Islamic State and the DAP has been consistent in opposing such a move from day one!

So, where does that leave us ?

Looks like we are stuck with the current BN?

Anyone care to update me as to whether the BA are ready to rumble against the BN?


Terang Bulan said...

Assalamualaikum Bro Mamu,

There are three problem,mainly:-
- internal; among ourselves in the Parti (the muslim who weak in faith) but give their support, but still they have potential to tarnish the image.

- Internal but inter Party; between BA and UMNO. It is clear that UMNO had done a considerable damage in dividing the race and giving a wrong perception on Islam. Not much of application or practice of True Islam in M'sia.

- External; between us Moslem and Non-Moslem, especially that against us. Unfortunately, their population is nearly overcoming us.

We can't do like Taliban did, such shock will deliver catastrophe at the end. How can u throw one stone to kill more than one bird. For me, the priority is to topple the one that think they are moslem but at the same time selling our religion for the sake of good living in this world.

Pas havent done anything to tackle DAP??? Pas did something in Kelantan to tackle Chinese.... Its not easy, it might take another 10 years for Non-Moslem in the whole M'sia to accept the goodness in Islam instead of rejecting our Syariah Law and Islamic Constitution. Refer to Prophet history, its very much the same now.

We need to show it by applying it through diplomatical way (eg PRU). Not by secular way done by UMNO.

There is more from me to say, but this is enough, you get my idea already.


davors said...

i think we probably gonna stuck with BN for some time more...

BA might not seems to be an alternative line to lead the country... but i guess we need to vote them up...
1. to let them have the chance to lead... e.g. lead a states...
2. to let BN know this country is powered by the rakyat...

not meant to be racist...
i am a chinese.. and not a muslim...
but if my election area is between PAS and BN... i will go for PAS...

We need a stronger OPPOSITION!!!

just my 2 cents..

mahaguru58 said...

Wa'alaikumsalam Terang Bulan,

Very clear reasons you have given me.

I agree that the present state of affairs concerning the BA's preparedness to run Malaysia is grossly lacking but I seriously hope that the Opposition hotshots get their act right and pose a really credible challenge in running the show instead of remaining the bloody Opposition all these 50 years!

I have shared my ideas with PAS Youth Chief YB Salahudin Ayub but it remains to be seen as to whether he might be able to get the old school amongst the PAS leadership to reformat certain mindsets and be a more proactive political party?

The BA has to get its coalition organized and offer us a viable alternative lineup to government failing which they might as well close shop and leave it to the current regime to loot the nation blind.

UMNO has had its way far too long but it is due to the reason that the Opposition are just too damn busy fighting amongst themselves especially PAS and DAP!

mahaguru58 said...

Thanks for sharing your views Brother Davors.

Whilst I appreciate your support for PAS, I do wish that instead of us getting a strong Opposition made up of PAS, DAP and PKR, I'd rather that those 3 parties get their act together and come up with a serious team of alternative government that will be able to pose a real challenge to the BN instead of remaining as the freaking Opposition all these 50 years!

What do you say to that?