Part of the Do'a Iftitah

"Verily my solats, my ibadah, my life and my death I surrender to Almighty Allah, Creator and Lord of all the worlds. Never will I associate anything with Him. So am I commanded and I am of those who are Muslims."

The Muslim Bloggers Alliance

The Muslim Bloggers Alliance
Bringing Muslim Bloggers Together

Monday, May 05, 2008

Star Online gets Ning Baizura's Mr.Manager fuming!

I thought that the Penang Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng's flying economy story has had its day in the news and has now been relegated to the media archives?

Well, not quite it seems as The Star Online had gone ahead and taken Mr.Manager's photo of Ning standing besides Lim Guan Eng and cropped the picture effectively removing Mr.Manager's blog url from the shot and published the story in its site!

The Star Online's cropping of Mr.Manager's photo, leaving out his url which makes him go ballistic!

The original photo complete with Mr.Manager's blog address.

I know that the mainstream media are sort of facing a dire situation of trying to be one step ahead of the blogosphere as thousands of bloggers are cropping up daily and reporting about this and that before the mainstream news reporters and journalists can get their articles edited and approved for publishing nowadays?

The reason Mr. Manager is pissed off is because this is a national newspaper doing the copy cut and paste job without properly acknowledging his rights over his intellectual property copyrights befitting their position as one of this nation's major news organization?

Even though The Star Online mentioned in their report that they took the photo from Jolly's blog, they should have at least published the photo containing Mr.Manager's url in total!

That's why Mr.Vernon is fuming mad at their overlooking his rights to be properly acknowledged in their belated news report on Guan Eng's economy flight!

If The Star Online has no qualms about borrowing a Blogger's photo and run a story based on his blog posting, why must it be so hard for them to publish the Blogger's url which he has rightfully watermarked on his picture?

What do you think should be done here?

Should The Star Online apologize to Mr.Manager in their paper or should Mr.Manager sue them for cropping his picture and removing his stake on the image which we bloggers published in full and acknowledged him to being the original author of the story?

Check out Mr.Manager's blog here to read what his readers are saying about the matter?

Frankly speaking, I believe that it is only right for both Bloggers and the Mainstream Media to work closely with each other and accord to the original authors their rights and acknowledge the source of any material that either party takes and publishes in either the blogs or the print / broadcast media or even in the entertainment or movie industry whenever such a matter takes place?

Bloggers rely on the mainstream media as much as we see the major media companies having to obtain material from the Blogosphere.

All it takes is according to each other a bit of respect and common courtesy.

Don't you agree?

7 comments: said...

This is not the first time The Star did that. Recently, they took foodblogger, Babe In the City's food photo and cropped off her URL and use it on their online site. They didn't give any credit to her. She found out, was furious but the staff apologised to her.

Samuel Goh Kim Eng said...

Any journalist worth his salt
Will know about copyright, right?
But with too much beer and not enough malt
'Strange' things are done when the head is still light

(C) Samuel Goh Kim Eng - 050508
Mon. 5th May 2008.

MAHAGURU58 said...

What a shameful thing to do?

The Star really needs to practice proper ethics of journalism and pay for the photos it pinches from Bloggers if it wants to crop out the Bloggers watermark or blog url?

Has The Star lost it's integrity as a major news publishing company?

Surely paying the photo owner his or her dues and acknowledging them is not such a very hard thing to do?

The Mainstream Media are fast losing any vestiges of claim to truthfulness and attestation to them being accountable for their actions.

Can Bloggers sue them for damages?

Mr Manager said...

Hi saudara Zainol,

Vernon terharu atas sokongan saudara! Berita terkini - pihak Star Online telah dimaklumkan mengenai ketidakpuasan saya.

Kesudahannya? Kita tunggu dan lihat.


ajami said...

Salaam Zainol,

fyi, kalau 'entertainment blogger' segah Vernon boleh terkena , apatah lagi saya!

read this:

..tapi tulah, kami 'entertainment blogger' tetap tahu bahawasanya kami lagik updated dr portal2 rasmi tu!.. huhu!

MAHAGURU58 said...

May peace be upon you Brother Vernon,

I am pleased to learn that Dato Wong Chun Wai, the Group Chief Editor of The Star has apologized to you for the oversight of the newspaper's staff in using your photo without giving you due accord and for the cropping of your blog's url from the said image in their online portal.

Let this be a lesson to all parties to not repeat such an erroneous slip up when using another's intellectual property.

All we have to do is to ask for permission or give due mention to the owner or author of the taken material.

All my best wishes for your blogging efforts, brother Vernon.


Mr Manager said...

Salaam saudara Zainol

Two words are all that I want to hear, "I'm sorry." And Star has said them.

Thank you once again for your support.